Whether you're looking to satisfy your sweet tooth, order dessert for a special occasion, or surprise someone you love with a delicious treat, there are plenty of unique dessert shops in the Red Lion area to visit. From cookies and cakes to ice cream and candy, there's no shortage of ways to indulge. Read on to discover seven of the best dessert shops in Red Lion, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding area.

The Sugar Rose Bake Shop

A slice of red velvet cake

Image via Unsplash by amirali mirhashemian

This family-owned bakeshop offers some of the highest quality desserts in the area. In 2020, it was even voted the best bakery, cupcake, and dessert shop in York by Clipper Magazine and Local Flavor. Whether you're looking for a custom cake for an upcoming celebration, a package of handcrafted truffles for someone special, or a delicious cookie platter to bring to the office, The Sugar Rose Bake Shop in Red Lion, Pennsylvania, has you covered.

Just make sure to pre-order some of its famous French macarons ahead of time so they don't sell out before you visit. The Sugar Rose Bake Shop also offers diabetic, keto, gluten-free, and vegan dessert options, making it easy to find a treat for everyone you care about. 

Providence Divine Cakes and Pastries

Indulge in a truly elegant dessert from Providence Divine Cakes and Pastries. Located just outside of Red Lion in York, Pennsylvania, this popular bakeshop specializes in crafting beautiful cakes for weddings and other occasions. Providence Divine Cakes and Pastries also offers unique cookies, miniature pastries, cupcakes, bread, French macarons, and other desserts. 

Stop in to see its gorgeous display of baked goods or place an order online to make sure you have the perfect treats for your next event. Cake orders require a minimum of one to two weeks' notice, but they're always are plenty of 6-inch and 8-inch round cakes that are baked fresh daily available for purchase.


Treat yourself to something truly unique and delicious at MarshmallowMBA. This adorable dessert shop crafts gourmet marshmallows with the finest ingredients available. If these decadent, melt-in-your-mouth marshmallows aren't enough to convince you to visit MarshmallowMBA in York, Pennsylvania, the S'mork will be. Described as s'mores on a fork, these fun desserts feature an extra-large, homemade marshmallow that's dipped in chocolate and coated with crunchy toppings.

Some popular S'mork flavors include chocolate cherry, Irish cream, fire toasted vanilla, and double chocolate sea salt caramel. S'morks are a fun treat for kids and an excellent gift for someone special. MarshmallowMBA also offers gluten-free flavors and provides custom packaging for large orders and special events. 

Safe and Sweet

If you're looking for keto-friendly dessert options, Safe and Sweet has an entire menu of baked goods just for you. Satisfy your cravings without the guilt by indulging in handcrafted donuts, truffles, cookies, cinnamon rolls, and more. Dedicated to bringing healthier treat options to York, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding area, Safe and Sweet's lineup of desserts also features items that are gluten-free, vegan, paleo, and diabetic-friendly. 

All the ingredients are organic, fair trade, and non-GMO to provide the highest quality possible. Safe and Sweet even offers a few savory items, like homemade pizza sauce, pizza crust, and garlic knots to make eating a healthy dinner feel like a real treat. Keep an eye on Safe and Sweet's social media pages to learn about upcoming classes, like holiday cookie decorating sessions, for even more fun. 

Janina's Fine Desserts

Janina's Fine Desserts specializes in crafting European delicacies and custom cakes for every occasion. Baked from scratch using only the freshest ingredients, each dessert is sure to leave your mouth watering for more. From Danish pastries and croissants to Polish shortbread cookies and opera cakes, you're sure to find something you love. 

Janina's Fine Desserts also offers a wide selection of bite-sized treats, including macarons, individual cheesecakes, and mini fruit tarts, which are a fun option to serve guests at large events. Pop in to pick up dessert, but stay for breakfast, lunch, or coffee. Janina's Fine Desserts has a full menu of omelets, waffles, sandwiches, soups, salads, espresso drinks, and more. 

All About Brownies

Also just outside of Red Lion in York, Pennsylvania, All About Brownies is a family-run bakery that dishes up some of the most delectable desserts in the area. Featuring gourmet brownies in a variety of flavors, this bakeshop offers individual slices, as well as 10-inch brownie cakes for those who simply can't get enough. Some of its most popular flavors include cookie dough, espresso, peanut butter cup, and walnut. If you can't choose just one type of brownie to try, opt for the Philly sampler instead to get a few slices of each.

All About Brownies also offers other sweet treats, like milk chocolate pretzels, cookies, and homemade peanut butter cups. You can even pick up a container of its famous ultimate blondie cookie dough to warm up at home with your favorite ice cream. The team at All About Brownies is always coming up with exciting new specials, so keep an eye on its social media pages or stop in today to try one of its latest creations.

Sweet Willow's Creamery

Nothing beats a scoop of handcrafted ice cream from Sweet Willow's Creamery on a hot summer day. Founded in 2003, Sweet Willow's Creamery takes pride in making fresh ice cream flavors every day using only the finest ingredients. In addition to classic flavors like butter pecan and chocolate chip cookie dough, you'll find unique options like cotton candy and Indonesian Sumatra. Sweet Willow's Creamery also offers plenty of ice creams that are vegan, frozen yogurts, sorbets, and treats that don't contain sugar.

Visit its location in York, Pennsylvania, or follow it on social media to see where its ice cream truck, the Willowship, is going to be this week. You can even contact Sweet Willow's Creamery online to reserve the Willowship for your next big event. 

We hope you enjoyed our team's list of the best dessert shops near Red Lion, Pennsylvania. Did we miss one of your favorite bakeries or restaurants? Drop us a line to tell us all about it, so we can make sure to include it in one of our upcoming blog posts. 

Categories: Social